Both Conventional and E-cigarettes are Dangerous, Doctor Says

16 January 2020 12:38 WIB

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - Electric cigarettes (e-cigarettes) that are present in Indonesia are becoming increasingly common day by day. Many studies mention that it can give the same taste as conventional cigarettes do. Some even say that the advantage of e-cigarette that it has fewer negative effects to your body.

But is it true? General Chairman of the Indonesian Respiratory Association (PDPI), Agus Dwi Susanto denies it. He said that the public must be educated that both conventional cigarette and e-cigarettes have the same negative impact on health.

Agus also explained that conventional cigarettes and electric are considered equal because they consist of the same chemicals. Moreover, both types of cigarettes also contained nicotine.

“Meaning both cigarettes can cause addiction and in the long term can cause cardiovascular problems, such as heart attack,” he said in a Media Gathering along with the Ministry of Health in Jakarta, January 15, 2020.

Besides the nicotine, both conventional and e-cigarettes also contained toxic. According to Agus, toxic on those cigarettes can cause lung inflammation.

“This can increase higher risk of asthma, acute respiratory infections (ISPA), and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (PPOK),” he explained.

Lastly, the dangerous content of conventional and electric cigarettes is carcinogens. Agus explained that carcinogens are substance that can cause cancer.

"In conventional cigarettes, carcinogens are found in tar. Whereas in electronic cigarettes, carcinogenic compounds are broken down into nitrosamines and PM 2.5," he said.

For this reason, Agus stressed that people should stop using e-cigarettes because both conventional and electric cigarettes are dangerous.

"Forget any e-cigarettes and conventional cigarettes, the most important thing is getting healthier overall, "he said.

Sarah Ervina Dara Siyahailatua | Safira Andini

E-Cigarette Cartridges Subjected to Tobacco Tax

20 November 2020

E-Cigarette Cartridges Subjected to Tobacco Tax

The Finance Ministry has classified e-cigarette cartridges as alternative products of tobacco or HPTL, subjecting it to existing taxes.


Muhammadiyah Officially Labels Vaping Haram

24 Januari 2020

Muhammadiyah Officially Labels Vaping Haram

Muhammadiyah has officially labeled vaping or e-cigarettes haram and called on non-smokers to refrain from it at all costs.


Trump Administration Restricts Some E-cigarette Flavors

3 Januari 2020

Trump Administration Restricts Some E-cigarette Flavors

The Trump administration on Thursday announced a ban on some popular e-cigarette flavors, including fruit and mint.


E-Cigarette with Herbal Liquid Still Dangerous, Says Doctor

27 November 2019

E-Cigarette with Herbal Liquid Still Dangerous, Says Doctor

The Indonesian Society of Respirology declared e-cigarettes that use herbal liquids still present health risks.


Philip Morris, Altria Ditch Merger Talks amid Vaping Crackdown

25 September 2019

Philip Morris, Altria Ditch Merger Talks amid Vaping Crackdown

The abandonment of the mega-merger comes at a time when e-cigarettes and vaping are facing intense regulatory scrutiny across the world.


Cases of Vaping-related Illness Rise to 530 in U.S.

20 September 2019

Cases of Vaping-related Illness Rise to 530 in U.S.

The U.S. health officials say there are now 530 confirmed and probable cases and seven deaths from severe lung-related illnesses tied to vaping.


Depok Eyeing to Ban E-Cigarettes, Vaping in Certain Area

19 September 2019

Depok Eyeing to Ban E-Cigarettes, Vaping in Certain Area

The local administration of Depok City is eyeing to ban the use of electric cigarette or vapes in certain locations.


India Bans E-Cigarettes

18 September 2019

India Bans E-Cigarettes

The ban cuts off a huge market from e-cigarette makers at a time when the number of people smoking worldwide is declining.


Vape Lacks Distribution Permit, Contains Harmful Substances: BPOM

17 September 2019

Vape Lacks Distribution Permit, Contains Harmful Substances: BPOM

BPOM head Penny K. Lukito stressed that his agency did not issue a distribution permit for vape or e-cigarette as it contains harmful materials.


KPAI: E-Cigarette Possibly Exposes Children to Illegal Drugs

26 Juni 2019

KPAI: E-Cigarette Possibly Exposes Children to Illegal Drugs

KPAI commissioner Sitti Hikmawati said that electronic cigarettes or e-cigarettes increased the possibility of children to be exposed to illegal drugs