Cleaning Up the Judges

Translator

Tempo.co

Editor

Laila Afifa

4 October 2019 12:26 WIB

illustration of court hammer. legaljuice.com

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - A suspicious aroma is starting to emerge around the controversial Supreme Court ruling that quashed the conviction of former chairman of the Indonesian Bank Restructuring Agency Syafruddin Arsyad Temenggung. It has come to light that Syamsul Rakan Chaniago, one of the three judges who heard the case, met with Syafruddin’s attorney, Ahmad Yani, two weeks before the judges’ ruling. Firm action must be taken against this judge, and the ruling needs to be reexamined.

Syafruddin had been sentenced to 15 years in jail in the corruption case involving the issuing of a document certifying repayment of the loan from the Bank Indonesia Liquidity Assistance (BLBI) that had been received by Bank Dagang Nasional Indonesia (BDNI). The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) prosecutor accused Syafruddin of absolving the remainder of the BDNI debt for no clear reason. As a result of this, BDNI owner Sjamsul Nursalim avoided losing Rp4.58 trillion.

In the ruling at the Jakarta High Court, Syafruddin was said to have committed corruption together with Sjamsul and his wife, Itjih Nursalim, along with the Coordinating Minister for the Economy, who was also the chairman of the Financial Sector Policy Committee, Dorodjatun Kuntjoro-Jakti. By acquitting Syafruddin, the cases involving Sjamsul, Itjih and Dorodjatun also ended.

The ruling by the Supreme Court, in this case, had seemed irregular from the outset. How is it possible that three judges could have three different opinions and that the final ruling was only taken based upon the different categories of these opinions? As well as Syamsul Rakan Chaniago, who took the view that the case was a civil law matter, Judge Mohamad Askin said that the Syafruddin case was simply an administrative matter. Only judge Salman Luthan, agreed with the guilty verdict on Syafruddin. As a result, Syafruddin was acquitted because Askin and Syamsul agreed that the case is not a criminal one.

Therefore, the findings of the Supreme Court’s Supervisory Board concerning violations of the code of ethics and judicial conduct guidelines by Syamsul Rakan deserves appreciation. However, punishment from the oversight agency in the form of the revocation of Syamsul’s judicial authority for six months is not enough. After all, Syamsul is due to retire in exactly six months. The punishment for rotten judges should be more severe. He should be dishonorably dismissed from his position.

Therefore, the Judicial Commission must follow up on this case and impose heavy punishment on Syamsul. As the body that carries out to the constitutional mandate to preserve the respect, dignity and conduct of judges, the Commission must not allow a judge such as Syamsul to escape from heavier punishment.

The evidence of Syamsul’s wrongdoing is undeniable. There is a CCTV recording that proves that Syamsul met with Ahmad Yani in a cafe in Plaza Indonesia, Central Jakarta. The meeting lasted almost an hour. There is also evidence of a telephone conversation between Syamsul and Ahmad Yani two weeks beforehand. All of this happened when the judges panel for the Syamsul case was intensively discussing the case.

The KPK must use the facts that have been uncovered in the violations of ethics by Syamsul as new evidence in the reexamination of the Syafruddin case. The endeavor to uncover corruption in the issuing of BLBI debt repayment documents can no longer be delayed. The Supreme Court no longer has any reason not to put right this irregular ruling. The dignity and integrity of the Supreme Court as the last bastion of justice in this country is at stake.

Read the Complete Story in this Week's Edition of Tempo English Magazine



President Orders Mahfud MD to Abolish Justice System 'Mafia'

2 jam lalu

President Orders Mahfud MD to Abolish Justice System 'Mafia'

Mahfud MD reiterated President Jokowi's concern regarding mafia in the justice system. Intends to implement reform.


KPK Reveals Challenge in Validating Lukas Enembe's Declining Health

1 hari lalu

KPK Reveals Challenge in Validating Lukas Enembe's Declining Health

KPK doctors tasked to validate the illness suffered by Papua governor Lukas Enembe had difficulties in proving it.


Supreme Court Chief Justice Criticized Following Arrest of MA Judge

2 hari lalu

Supreme Court Chief Justice Criticized Following Arrest of MA Judge

Criminal law observer urged the Supreme Court (MA) leader to commence a structural reform following the KPK arrest of a court judge.


ICW Calls for KPK's Assertiveness in Lukas Enembe Graft Investigation

2 hari lalu

ICW Calls for KPK's Assertiveness in Lukas Enembe Graft Investigation

ICW urged the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) to issue an ultimatum to forcefully collect Papua governor Lukas Enembe.


KPK to Probe Allegations of Money Laundering in Casinos by Papua Gov Lukas Enembe

2 hari lalu

KPK to Probe Allegations of Money Laundering in Casinos by Papua Gov Lukas Enembe

KPK says it would investigate the allegations of money laundering at casinos by Papua Governor Lukas Enembe.


KPK Summons Again Papua Governor Lukas Enembe Over Corruption Case

2 hari lalu

KPK Summons Again Papua Governor Lukas Enembe Over Corruption Case

KPK issued yet another summons for Papua Governor Lukas Enembe who is embroiled in a Rp1 billion gratification criminal case


KPK Arrests Supreme Court Justice Sudrajad Dimyati

4 hari lalu

KPK Arrests Supreme Court Justice Sudrajad Dimyati

The KPK arrested Justice Sudrajad Dimyati as a suspect in the alleged case of bribery at the Supreme Court.


Corruption Suspect Supreme Court Justice Agung Sudrajad Dimyati Has Rp10.77bn in Assets

4 hari lalu

Corruption Suspect Supreme Court Justice Agung Sudrajad Dimyati Has Rp10.77bn in Assets

KPK has named Supreme Court Justice Agung Sudrajad Dimyati and several others as suspects in the alleged bribery.


KPK Names Supreme Court Justice Sudrajad Dimyati Suspect in Bribery Case

5 hari lalu

KPK Names Supreme Court Justice Sudrajad Dimyati Suspect in Bribery Case

The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) names Supreme Court Justice Sudrajad Dimyati and nine others as suspects in the alleged bribery case.


Supreme Court Judge Nabbed in KPK Sting Operation

5 hari lalu

Supreme Court Judge Nabbed in KPK Sting Operation

KPK arrested a supreme court judge in one of its sting operations (OTT) carried out in Jakarta and Semarang.