4 Controversies in the `RUU Permusikan` Draft Music Bill

4 February 2019 11:52 WIB

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - Hundreds of musicians in the national coalition against the draft music bill or ‘Koalisi Nasional Tolak RUU Permusikan’ collectively believes that Article 19 contained in the bill will suppress musicians’ freedom of expression.

“From its editorial obscurity, the unclear subject or object that is regulated, up to the fundamental issue on the freedom of expression in music,” said indie musician and coalition member Rara Sekar in a written statement dated Sunday, February 3.

Musician Danilla Riyadi also views that the bill can potentially overlap other regulations stated in the Copyright Law, ITE Law, and Print and Record Works Handover Law.

Here are 4 controversial points in the draft music bill (RUU Permusikan) being opposed by the national coalition of musicians:

  1. Elastic and Ambiguous Law

The coalition found a number of ambiguous articles in the draft bill which was highlighted by Efek Rumah Kaca vocalist Cholil Mahmud, who said that the bill’s Article 5 contains rules with stretched interpretations. He maintains that Article 5 may open room for anyone to persecute creative processes they simply disagree on with rules against creating music containing elements of blasphemy up to provocative music.

  1. Marginalizes Independence and Pro with Major Industries

Endah Widiastuti from ‘Endah n Resa’ said that RUU Permusikan fails to understand the underground music movement with drafts seemingly supporting major industries. It is indicated in the rule overseeing musical worker certifications and Article 10 that oversee music distributions that support large industries and leaves a small margin for musicians to distribute their work independently.

  1. Obtrudes and Discriminative

One of the rules in the RUU Permusikan mentions musicians’ competence tests and certifications. Composer Mondo Gascoro said even though a number of countries have competence tests, they are left as choices and not state-requirements. This single rule can potentially discriminate against self-taught musicians and bar them from performing just because they have not participated in a competence-test.

  1. Contains Public Information and Regulates Redundancies 

Several Articles contain obscure editorial on what the bill oversees and who monitors them, such as Article 11 and 15 that only mention general information on how to distribute known and practiced musical works and how the public enjoys such work. This is seen as a rule that lacks the weight and value on this level of Law.

Article 13 in the RUU Permusikan on the mandatory Indonesian language label is also criticized as an attempt to intrude the right of a musician to use language as a form of art itself.

TEMPO.CO



Draft Music Bill Officially Dropped from DPR's Priority List

18 Juni 2019

Draft Music Bill Officially Dropped from DPR's Priority List

The draft music bill (RUU Permusikan) that was infamous for the amount of backlash it garnered is dropped from the 2019 national legislative program.


Musician Coalition KNTL RUUP Talks of KPI's Song Ban Controversy

28 Februari 2019

Musician Coalition KNTL RUUP Talks of KPI's Song Ban Controversy

Musicians in KNTL RUUP discussed the recent controversial curbing against 17 Western songs by the West Java Indonesian Broadcasting Commission (KPI).


Kaka Slank Rejects RUU Permusikan, Set to Meet Anang Hermansyah

12 Februari 2019

Kaka Slank Rejects RUU Permusikan, Set to Meet Anang Hermansyah

Musician Kaka Slank plans to meet legislative member Anang Hermansyah in an attempt to reject the controversial Draft Music Bill (RUU Permusikan).


Musicians Send Recommendation Against Music Draft Bill to DPR

12 Februari 2019

Musicians Send Recommendation Against Music Draft Bill to DPR

Musicians and art workers in Malang declined the music draft bill or RUU Permusikan because of its articles that promote controversy.


Interview with Anang Hermansyah on the Debated Music Draft Bill

8 Februari 2019

Interview with Anang Hermansyah on the Debated Music Draft Bill

Tempo was granted the chance to interview Anang Hermansyah on the Music Draft Bill (RUU Permusikan) that he initiated back in 2015.


RUU Permusikan: Singer-Turned-Legislator Anang to Meet Musicians

6 Februari 2019

RUU Permusikan: Singer-Turned-Legislator Anang to Meet Musicians

Anang Hermansyah said he welcomes every criticism and advice admits that there are many points in RUU Permusikan that need fixing.


53 Indie Musicians Nix Music Draft Bill

4 Februari 2019

53 Indie Musicians Nix Music Draft Bill

The musicians say the music draft bill or RUU Permusikan will hamper and curb their creativity.


Glenn Fredly on the Much-Debated Draft Music Bill Timeline

4 Februari 2019

Glenn Fredly on the Much-Debated Draft Music Bill Timeline

Indonesia Music Conference (KAMI) Leader Glenn Fredly recalled how the RUU Permusikan draft bill was formed.


Music Draft Bill a Flashback to Indonesia's New Order Era

1 Februari 2019

Music Draft Bill a Flashback to Indonesia's New Order Era

Musicians say that the proposed draft bill on music will force them to share the same fate as past musicians under Indonesia's New Order.