Constitutional Court Verdict on Election Dispute Sets 'Bad Precedent', Economist Says

Translator

Najla Nur Fauziyah

Editor

Laila Afifa

Selasa, 23 April 2024 22:32 WIB

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - Director of the Institute for Demographic and Poverty Studies (Ideas) Yusuf Wibisono believes that the Constitutional Court (MK) verdict on the presidential election dispute will set a bad precedent for democracy in Indonesia. He believes that the politicization of social assistance will later be a normalized state practice.

"The politicization of social assistance and the use of public budgets for the electoral interests of those in power will become increasingly widespread in the future," said Yusuf in a written statement to Tempo on Tuesday, April 23, 2024.

The economist said he was surprised that the majority of Constitutional Court justices found no evidence of interference by President Joko Widodo or Jokowi to win the Prabowo Subianto and Gibran Rakabuming Raka. According to him, the politicization of social assistance is clearly aimed at winning the running pair.

"The Constitutional Court's conclusion is even more surprising because the court then asked for social assistance to be halted ahead of elections," he said.

Yusuf explained that the Constitutional Court panel of judges also dismissed the argument about the massive distribution of social assistance ahead of the election. Yusuf believed the social protection budget clearly showed an electoral budget cycle pattern.

In detail, he stated that the budget increased significantly during the pandemic, from Rp308 trillion in 2019 to Rp498 trillion in 2020. Yusuf said this was a natural growth since Indonesia was facing a crisis.

He explained further that the social protection budget decreased in 2021 and 2022, once the threats of a crisis passed. However, the budget rose again ahead of the 2024 elections from Rp439 trillion in 2023 to Rp494 trillion, a 12.4 percent growth. The social assistance budget also increased significantly ahead of the elections.

"The social assistance budget has increased significantly and massively ahead of the presidential election, even though there was no extraordinary economic crisis," he said.

SAVERO ARISTIA WIENANTO

Editor’s Choice: Gibran Rakabuming Awaits Prabowo's Order Post Court's Verdict on Election Dispute

Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News

Related News

Jokowi Signals Possible Extension of Social Assistance Until December 2024

4 hari lalu

Jokowi Signals Possible Extension of Social Assistance Until December 2024

President Joko Widodo or Jokowi signaled that social assistance could be extended until the end of this year.

Read More

Jokowi Assures Regional Head Elections Set in November

9 hari lalu

Jokowi Assures Regional Head Elections Set in November

Jokowi ensures that the 2024 regional head elections would be held according to schedule.

Read More

Top Court to Start Hearing for Legislative Election Dispute Today

19 hari lalu

Top Court to Start Hearing for Legislative Election Dispute Today

The Constitutional Court (MK) will hold the first hearing on legislative election dispute today, Monday, April 29, 2024.

Read More

Ganjar Pranowo Absent in Prabowo-Gibran Victory Declaration, Seen Cycling in Yogyakarta

23 hari lalu

Ganjar Pranowo Absent in Prabowo-Gibran Victory Declaration, Seen Cycling in Yogyakarta

Ganjar Pranowo says he was not invited to Prabowo-Gibran's declaration ceremony today.

Read More

Jokowi: The Govt Respects Court Ruling on Election Dispute

24 hari lalu

Jokowi: The Govt Respects Court Ruling on Election Dispute

Jokowi responded to the Constitutional Court (MK) verdict which rejected all claims in the presidential election dispute.

Read More

MUI: Everyone Must Accept MK Decision on Election Dispute Willingly

24 hari lalu

MUI: Everyone Must Accept MK Decision on Election Dispute Willingly

Indonesian Ulema Council or MUI said that they respect the Constitutional Court's (MK) decision on the 2024 presidential election dispute.

Read More

Indonesia's President-elect Prabowo: It's Time to Prepare for the Future

25 hari lalu

Indonesia's President-elect Prabowo: It's Time to Prepare for the Future

Indonesia's President-elect Prabowo Subianto expressed his gratitude for the conclusion of the 2024 presidential election dispute process.

Read More

Anies Baswedan Concedes to Prabowo as Court Rejects Election Petition

25 hari lalu

Anies Baswedan Concedes to Prabowo as Court Rejects Election Petition

Losing presidential candidate pair Anies Baswedan - Muhaimin Iskandar congratulated their victorious rivals, Prabowo Subianto and Gibran Rakabuming.

Read More

Anies Baswedan Meets Surya Paloh at NasDem Tower

25 hari lalu

Anies Baswedan Meets Surya Paloh at NasDem Tower

Anies Baswedan meets with Surya Paloh at NasDem Tower after the reading of the Constitutional Court decision.

Read More

Top Court Justice Saldi Isra Delivers Dissenting Opinion on Election Dispute Hearing

25 hari lalu

Top Court Justice Saldi Isra Delivers Dissenting Opinion on Election Dispute Hearing

MK Justice Saldi Isra assessed that the politicization of social assistance was proven to have occurred in the 2024 presidential election.

Read More