Lupa Kata Sandi? Klik di Sini

atau Masuk melalui

Belum Memiliki Akun Daftar di Sini


atau Daftar melalui

Sudah Memiliki Akun Masuk di Sini

Konfirmasi Email

Kami telah mengirimkan link aktivasi melalui email ke rudihamdani@gmail.com.

Klik link aktivasi dan dapatkan akses membaca 2 artikel gratis non Laput di koran dan Majalah Tempo

Jika Anda tidak menerima email,
Kirimkan Lagi Sekarang

Arbitrary Tax Increase

Translator

TEMPO

Editor

Laila Afifa

25 June 2021 10:52 WIB

TEMPO.CO, JakartaThe government'splan to increase value-added tax and widen its coverage triggers controversy. The key is build public trust.

If a nation is facing difficulties collecting tax from its citizens, who is to blame? In Indonesia, where the tax ration continues to fall - last year it was only around 8 percent - and is among the lowest in the world, it is usually taxpayers who are blamed. It must be admitted that compliance with tax obligations is still low. But attacking the problem downstream without looking at the issues upstream is clearly a serious mistake.

The more fundamental roots of the problem are in the hands of the government. Since the administration of President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, the government has tried to improve the taxation system, including giving large incentives to taxation directorate-general employees. But this still led to the emergence of tax brokers such as Gayus Tambunan and Angin Prayitno.

Therefore, the low level of compliance with tax obligations has a direct link to the lack of public trust in the government. People's unwillingnes to pay tax needs to be seen as a consequence. Who wants to pay tax if the results f their hard work are simply frittered away? From building new capital and purchasing weapons to be used against some unclear enemy to funding luxury lifestyles of officials. So it is not simply a problem with the taxation system, but also a matter of transparency and accountability in running the country.

It is against this background that the plan to expand the coverage of value added tax through the General Provisions of Taxation Procedures Law has triggered widespread opposition. under this omnibus law, the government plans to impose taxes on the purchase of basic necessities, education and healthcare under the category of goods and services usually consumed by higher income people.

Using the excuse of equality and justice, the aim of expanding value-added tax (VAT) is clear: to increase government revenues. From the outset, there are problems with the complexity and the implementation of this plan. Let us take the example of beef used by Finance MinisterSri Mulyani in a working meeting with the House of Representatives (DPR) last week. According to Minister Sri, VAT will only be applied to premium class beef, such as wagyu and kobe. In practice, at present tax is already paid three times on these types of meet. As well as import duties, wagyu bought in supermarkets is already subject to VAT. After being prepared and consumed by customers in hotels, cafes or restaurants, the meat is still subject to restaurant tax.

In other words, rather than being a form of equality, it is discrimination. What is more, people able to afford these high-quality products already pay more income tax. If they have not paid their tax in line with the regulations, this is a problem of collection and the integrity of tax officials. In the end, it all returns to the problem of public trust in our tax system.

There is nothing wrong with the government trying to increase the tax ratio. But the methods used must be realistic and must begin from fundamentals. An increase in public trust is the key.

Read the Complete Story in Tempo English Magazine



Stopping Animal Torture Video from Indonesia

22 jam lalu

Stopping Animal Torture Video from Indonesia

Indonesia is the world's largest producer of animal torture video content. This is a result of weak law enforcement.


Academic Misconduct on our Campuses

1 hari lalu

Academic Misconduct on our Campuses

The image of our higher education is once again damaged by revelations of alleged academic misconduct in scientific publications by a professor.


The Corrupt Design in Lobster Downstreaming

2 hari lalu

The Corrupt Design in Lobster Downstreaming

The Ministry of Fisheries produced some strange regulations about the cultivation and export of lobsters.


Legal Tinkering to Pay Political Debt

7 hari lalu

Legal Tinkering to Pay Political Debt

President Jokowi is planning to grant mining concessions to mass organizations. Paying political debts.


Questioning Modern Spiritual Slavery

7 hari lalu

Questioning Modern Spiritual Slavery

Deifying habib is a characteristic of inferior mentality and religious feudalism. It has been cultivated since colonial times.


For the Sake of Educational Standards in Pesantren

8 hari lalu

For the Sake of Educational Standards in Pesantren

Many Islamic boarding schools (pesantren) are operating without permits. There needs to be standardization of these religious educational institutions


Evidence of Human Rights Violations at Rumoh Geudong

9 hari lalu

Evidence of Human Rights Violations at Rumoh Geudong

The human remains at Rumoh Geudong are strong evidence of human rights violations. The government has an obligation to uncover the truth.


The High Price of Our Legislative Seats

9 hari lalu

The High Price of Our Legislative Seats

Prospective legislators need to spend large amounts of money to garner votes in increasingly transactional elections. A simpler system is needed.


Govt Annuls Policy Restricting Migrant Workers' Carry-on Goods

10 hari lalu

Govt Annuls Policy Restricting Migrant Workers' Carry-on Goods

The government decides to revoke regulations restricting migrant workers' carry-on goods from aboard.


End the Military Exemption from Climate Mitigation

10 hari lalu

End the Military Exemption from Climate Mitigation

Emissions from conflicts and the military sector damage the environment. This is often ignored because of global political pressures.