Emasculating Oversight

Translator

Editor

Jumat, 24 April 2015 14:20 WIB

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The proposal of the board of directors of state-owned Telekomunikasi Indoneia (Telkom) must be sharply and intensively reviewed. They are recommending that certain functions involving the budget and share transactions should not require the approval of the commissioners. The government, as the majority shareholder of Telkom, must reject these proposals.


The intention to initiate these changes was revealed during a joint meeting between the board of directors and the commissioners or governing board last March 23. The directors want certain restrictions on executive action be eased, not requiring the board of commissioners' approval, to a minimum of 20 percent of the value of corporate shares, or Rp17 trillion.


According to regulations, only a shareholders meeting can alter the contents of the corporate charter. This means that the decision is now in the hands of the State-Owned Enterprises Ministry, as shareholder in the company, representing the government. If this proposal is approved, the authority of the commissioners to oversee state-owned companies will be under-sized. Yet, oversight is the most important aspect of corporate good governance.


The changes to the company's rules and regulations, if they are approved, will also give much grerater authority to the executives in managing the company. The directors can for example, sell without restriction, its subsidiary Dayamitra Telekomunikasi or Mitratel. This company owns 4,000 telecommunication towers and is valued at about Rp9.8 trillion. So far, the plan to trade Mitratel for shares of Tower Bersama Infrastructure through backdoor listing has failed, because of the commissioners' lack of approval.


The new authority accorded to the board of directors, if approved, will make this trade/sale possible. In fact, this could enable Telkom to sell off all of its subsidiaries, without the approval of the commissioners. Telkomsel is the hardest to influence, perhaps because out of the many subsidiaries of Telkom, the asset of Telkomsel, at Rp17 trillion, has the highest value.


Telkom's Board of Commissioners should reject the proposal. SOEs Minister Rini Soemarno must also back the commissioners. They represent the interest of the shareholders in managing the company. To restrict their authority would be like tying the hands and legs of the shareholders themselves. Of course, they don't need to interfere in day-to-day management, but transactions involving big money, like that of Mitratel, cannot be left on its own. It must have the approval of the commissioners.


We should remember how the decision of the Megawati Soekarnoputri government to sell Indosat to Singapore-owned Temasek Holdings in 2002, was later questioned and regretted. It's not just about nationalism, as at that time, Indosat was performing well, but the government needed massive funding to cover its budget deficit. Indosat was seen as a very profitable telecommunications company.


Telkom is one of the state-owned companies that is healthy and continuously profitable. Besides a market capitalization of almost Rp300 trillion, last year, its revenue was Rp14.6 trillion. Minister Rini must ensure that such a potential is not ruined by corporate actions without the approval of its commissioners. To sell off the assets of a telecommunications company is like selling off the state's eyes and ears. (*)

Related News

The Risk with Free Lunch Program

1 hari lalu

The Risk with Free Lunch Program

A number of Jokowi's ministers are busy producing simulations of the free lunch program. There is a risk it will become a cash cow.

Read More

Mismanaged Plastic Waste

3 hari lalu

Mismanaged Plastic Waste

Ten percent of Indonesian plastic waste ends up in the ocean. It is time for a total ban on single-use plastic.

Read More

The Supreme Court's Lack of Ethics

4 hari lalu

The Supreme Court's Lack of Ethics

Alleged ethical violations by Supreme Court justices who were treated to a meal by an attorney underline the sorry state of our judicial system.

Read More

Sharing Out Ministerial Seats in a Big Cabinet

8 hari lalu

Sharing Out Ministerial Seats in a Big Cabinet

Prabowo Subianto intends to form a cabinet of 40 ministers. This will result in a bloated bureaucracy and wasted public money.

Read More

The Dark Threat of Surveillance Equipment

9 hari lalu

The Dark Threat of Surveillance Equipment

The surreptitious purchase of surveillance devices is a threat to democracy and people's rights to privacy. It is also prone to embezzlement and abuse

Read More

The Warning of a Banking Crisis

10 hari lalu

The Warning of a Banking Crisis

The OJK releases a new regulation obliging banks to increase their capital.

Read More

The Wrong Energy Transition Approach

11 hari lalu

The Wrong Energy Transition Approach

The Ombilin PLTU in Sumatra, which is a threat to the environment and human health, is being addressed using a bogus energy transition solution.

Read More

The Political Way to Fight Electoral Wrongdoing

15 hari lalu

The Political Way to Fight Electoral Wrongdoing

The Constitutional Court has failed to uphold justice in the face of electoral fraud. It is time to take the political route.

Read More

Legal Populism in the Tin Case

16 hari lalu

Legal Populism in the Tin Case

The Attorney General's Office needs to focus on the main perpetrators of corruption in tin trading in Bangka Belitung. Avoid legal populism.

Read More

A Domestic Recipe for the Middle East Conflict

17 hari lalu

A Domestic Recipe for the Middle East Conflict

The Middle East conflicts will harm the Indonesian economy. The solution is to improve the domestic economy.

Read More