Understanding France

Translator

Tempo.co

Editor

Laila Afifa

Jumat, 13 November 2020 06:45 WIB

A view shows the Champs Elysees avenue in Paris as a lockdown is imposed to slow the rate of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in France, March 20, 2020. French President Emmanuel Macron has ordered stringent restrictions on people's movement to slow the spread of the coronavirus. REUTERS/Gonzalo Fuentes

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - PRESIDENT Joko Widodo has done enough by joining in the condemnation of the speech by French President Emmanuel Macron. Indonesia and France are not enemies and the two nations have often worked together. Macron's comments must be seen as proportionate because France, unlike Indonesia, is a secular state.

The row started with the October 16 killing of Samuel Paty by a youth from Chechnya named Abdoullakh Abouyezidovitc. Paty was murdered because he used a cartoon of the Prophet Mohammed from the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo to teach freedom of opinion. Before discussing the cartoon, Paty invited Muslim students to leave his classroom if they were offended.

In his speech at Paty's funeral, Macron did not mention radical Islam. He only said that Paty was a victim of a mad conspiracy, lies, confusion, dislike of others and hatred of the secular nature of France. He also promised to defend France's freedom and secularism and to take stern action against those who violated it.

Macron did mention the problem of "Muslim separatism" at the beginning of October, when announcing the plan to strengthen the law designed to respond to Islamic radicalism. This new policy was drawn up in response to people using violence in the name of religion and also to protect French Muslims from other citizens. His intention was to free French Islam from foreign influences. At present, there are six million Muslims in France -- the highest number in Europe.

France is a nation that abides by the principle of secularism -- legally based separation of the government and religious institutions. The state also upholds freedom of expression that makes it possible for everybody to express their opinions as long as they do not incite hatred or violence or promote terrorism. According to French law, criticism of religion or religious symbols -- such as cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad or comics about Jesus -- are not forbidden.

The harsh reaction to Macron's speech was principally sparked by the comments from Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who accused Macron of reviving Islamophobia in the West. He also called on Muslims around the world to boycott French products. This call was accompanied by protests against France from a number of Islamic groups around the world, including in Indonesia.

Jokowi must not use this momentum to garner support from Muslims or to distract attention from the problems the government is facing. The Indonesian public is very sensitive about religious issues, but using religion to divert public attention is not a praiseworthy move.

Jokowi's statement could fan the flames and spur hard-line groups to take action in the name of Islam. If this happens, many people will be affected. Hatred could erupt, or at the very least become an underlying problem that could rise to the surface at any time.

Indonesia's Muslims should remain calm over this issue. France is not Indonesia. Something that is banned here may well be allowed in other countries. Our respect for religion and religious symbols should be accompanied by our willingness to respect differences -- both in culture and in the legal systems of other people, in other countries.

Read the Complete Story in Tempo English Magazine

Related News

Jokowi Responds Positively on Prabowo's Presidential Club Initiative, Hopes it Can Be Done Every Two Days

6 jam lalu

Jokowi Responds Positively on Prabowo's Presidential Club Initiative, Hopes it Can Be Done Every Two Days

Indonesian President Joko Widodo or Jokowi has responded positively to the idea of the Presidential Club

Read More

Prabowo Subianto to Form 'Presidential Club', Spokesperson Claims

1 hari lalu

Prabowo Subianto to Form 'Presidential Club', Spokesperson Claims

Prabowo Subianto's spokesperson, Dahnil Anzar Simanjuntak, spoke about Prabowo's desire to have regular meetings with former Indonesian presidents.

Read More

Jokowi Says Garuda Team's Achievement in U-23 Asian Cup Worthy of Appreciation

1 hari lalu

Jokowi Says Garuda Team's Achievement in U-23 Asian Cup Worthy of Appreciation

Jokowi believed the achievements of the Indonesian U-23 National Team in the 2024 Asian Cup were worthy of appreciation.

Read More

Jokowi Pushes for Agricultural Downstream to Stabilize Corn Prices

1 hari lalu

Jokowi Pushes for Agricultural Downstream to Stabilize Corn Prices

Jokowi is encouraging downstream to stabilize corn prices.

Read More

The Political Way to Fight Electoral Wrongdoing

1 hari lalu

The Political Way to Fight Electoral Wrongdoing

The Constitutional Court has failed to uphold justice in the face of electoral fraud. It is time to take the political route.

Read More

Jokowi Allows Up to 16-year Term for Village Heads

1 hari lalu

Jokowi Allows Up to 16-year Term for Village Heads

President Joko Widodo or Jokowi inked the ratification of Law No. 3 of 2024 on villages or the Village Law.

Read More

Jokowi Blames Great Harvest for Falling Corn Price

1 hari lalu

Jokowi Blames Great Harvest for Falling Corn Price

President Joko Widodo or Jokowi said that the price of corn is currently falling because of the peak harvest period in various regions of Indonesia.

Read More

Jokowi Upbeat for Indonesia Vs. Iraq in U-23 Asian Cup Third-place Playoff

2 hari lalu

Jokowi Upbeat for Indonesia Vs. Iraq in U-23 Asian Cup Third-place Playoff

Indonesian President Jokowi is optimistic that the national team's match against Iraq in the AFC U-23 Asian Cup tonight will end well for Indonesia.

Read More

Jokowi Inaugurates Rp1.4tn Tiuk Suntuk Dam in West Sumbawa

2 hari lalu

Jokowi Inaugurates Rp1.4tn Tiuk Suntuk Dam in West Sumbawa

President Jokowi inaugurates the Tiu Suntuk Dam in West Sumbawa, West Nusa Tenggara (NTB) on Thursday

Read More

Legal Populism in the Tin Case

2 hari lalu

Legal Populism in the Tin Case

The Attorney General's Office needs to focus on the main perpetrators of corruption in tin trading in Bangka Belitung. Avoid legal populism.

Read More