Investor-Unfriendly Regulations

Translator

Editor

Kamis, 1 Januari 1970 07:00 WIB

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - President Joko Widodo's objective to attract Rp3.5 quadrillion in foreign investment throughout his five-year term could turn out to be an unfulfilled dream if thousands of thorny regional regulations remain in force. It is a fact that the absurd regulations cooked up by little 'emperors' in the regions, in the forms of unfair levies and complex permit procedures, are gnawing at the country's economy like a chronic disease.


In the second year of his administration, Jokowi asked regional chief executives to repeal 3,143 such regulations, a measure critical to make Indonesia more competitive in attracting foreign investors. Amid a myriad of investment options available in other countries, our regulations must be attractive to investors. According to the World Bank's June 2015 index on the ease of doing business, Indonesia ranked a low 109th out of 189 countries. This leaves the government no choice but to fix the consequences of having delegated too much authority to regional chiefs.


The National Development Planning Agency's (Bappenas) assessment shows there are currently around 42,000 regulations, including 3,000 of which are problematic regional regulations. They prove not only to obstruct Indonesia's competitiveness, they are also a waste of money, given that trillions of rupiah are needed to document them. From 2001 to 2010, for example, a staggering budget of Rp14 trillion was spent to formulate various regulations.


These regulations are the results of arbitrary processes, and regional chiefs only use them to generate sharp increase in real regional incomes (PAD) for short periods of time, ignoring larger long-term objectives that can help boost economy and growth.


To tackle this issue, the home affairs ministry has instructed regional chief executives to work with their respective provincial and local councils to scrap those regulations. But the problem does not seem to go away so easily. Regional chiefs can still turn down this instruction and the central government does not have the authority to arbitrarily annul the regulations.


Law No. 32/2004 on Regional Governments regulates that the government can revoke regional regulations within 60 days after they are put into effect. Most of the regulations in question are more than one year old.


One alternative is to propose a judicial review to the Supreme Court. Article 24 of the 1945 Constitution states that the Supreme Court has the authority to review the legality of the laws and regulations. Nonetheless, not all problematic regional regulations violate the law. Regional chief executives can sue the government at administrative courts if the latter revokes regulations without legal grounds.


Consequently, with few options available, the central government must take the persuasive approach. Governors, regents and mayors must be convinced that their regions stand to gain more from scraping these regulations. The taxation system should be overhauled to ensure added PAD.


Apart from the above issues, the home affairs ministry should learn lesson from the consequences of its negligence in its oversight of regulations. In the future, it should exercise its right to revoke absurd regulations right from the start. (*)



Read the full story in this week's edition of Tempo English Magazine

Related News

The Political Way to Fight Electoral Wrongdoing

4 jam lalu

The Political Way to Fight Electoral Wrongdoing

The Constitutional Court has failed to uphold justice in the face of electoral fraud. It is time to take the political route.

Read More

Legal Populism in the Tin Case

1 hari lalu

Legal Populism in the Tin Case

The Attorney General's Office needs to focus on the main perpetrators of corruption in tin trading in Bangka Belitung. Avoid legal populism.

Read More

A Domestic Recipe for the Middle East Conflict

1 hari lalu

A Domestic Recipe for the Middle East Conflict

The Middle East conflicts will harm the Indonesian economy. The solution is to improve the domestic economy.

Read More

The Import Restrictions Boomerang

2 hari lalu

The Import Restrictions Boomerang

The restrictions on the imports of goods caused problems for many industries. They could become an opportunity for bribery and corruption.

Read More

Tin Vanishes, Humans and Nature Perish

6 hari lalu

Tin Vanishes, Humans and Nature Perish

The mining of tin causes serious environmental damage in Bangka Belitung. The number of children with intellectual disabilities and autism is rising.

Read More

Stopping Animal Torture Video from Indonesia

7 hari lalu

Stopping Animal Torture Video from Indonesia

Indonesia is the world's largest producer of animal torture video content. This is a result of weak law enforcement.

Read More

Academic Misconduct on our Campuses

8 hari lalu

Academic Misconduct on our Campuses

The image of our higher education is once again damaged by revelations of alleged academic misconduct in scientific publications by a professor.

Read More

The Corrupt Design in Lobster Downstreaming

8 hari lalu

The Corrupt Design in Lobster Downstreaming

The Ministry of Fisheries produced some strange regulations about the cultivation and export of lobsters.

Read More

Legal Tinkering to Pay Political Debt

13 hari lalu

Legal Tinkering to Pay Political Debt

President Jokowi is planning to grant mining concessions to mass organizations. Paying political debts.

Read More

Questioning Modern Spiritual Slavery

14 hari lalu

Questioning Modern Spiritual Slavery

Deifying habib is a characteristic of inferior mentality and religious feudalism. It has been cultivated since colonial times.

Read More