Expert Warns of Mud Risk Due to Sea Sand Dredging

September 29, 2024 | 08:40 pm

TEMPO.CO, Bogor - The head of the Center for Coastal and Marine Resources Studies at the Bogor Agricultural Institute (IPB), Professor Yonvitner, stated that material suction in shallow sea, especially sea sand, has the potential to increase water turbidity. Water that has been mixed with fine sediment usually will mix back with the water.

"If the extraction activities (of material) are near ecosystems, it could cause an increase in suspended solids," he told Tempo, Thursday, September 26, 2024.

The environmental risks discussed by Yonvitner are still related to the opening of the sea sand export tap. The professor at the Faculty of Fisheries and Marine Sciences at IPB assessed that trading sea sand from shallow sea would not be beneficial for Indonesia. Sand mining actually threatens ecosystems, as well as social and economic aspects.

According to Yonvitner, sand mining as well as sediments - as claimed by the government - has the potential to dredge up mud spread in deep waters. One of the impacts of dredging is changes in currents patterns, as well as water turbidity that disturbs fishing areas,

"The change in currents can also cause abrasion of the coast and sedimentation," he said.

The government recently reopened the sea sand export tap, which has been closed for the past two decades. Sea sand trade to foreign countries can be resumed through Government Regulation (PP) Number 26 of 2023 concerning the Management of Sedimentation Products in the Sea.

Revisions to two Minister of Trade Regulations (Permendag) in the export sector, namely Permendag Number 20 of 2024 and Permendag Number 21 of 2024, also facilitated the export of materials from within that saltwater. Currently, the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries (KKP) is reviewing and selecting 66 companies that have applied for permits to export sea sand.

President Joko Widodo claimed that the export is only for sediment deposits, not for sea sand. The sediment is also planned to be dredged due to disturbing the navigation routes of ships.

According to Yonvitner, PP Number 26 of 2023 has not regulated improvements from an ecological function perspective. The trading mechanism and profit-sharing of sea sand have also not involved funding for the conservation needs of the target mining areas. He mentioned there have been no clear studies on the new revisions of the two Permendag.

"There is no study on the risks to ecosystems, habitats, and the environment," he said.

TEMPO.CO | PETIR GARDA B

Editor's Choice: Sea Sand Export Poses No Benefits for Indonesia: Researcher

Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News


5 Jokowi-Era Policies Revoked Under Prabowo Administration

10 Juli 2025

5 Jokowi-Era Policies Revoked Under Prabowo Administration

Here are several policies from the Jokowi era that were cancelled during President Prabowo Subianto's administration. What are they?


Indonesia's Supreme Court Cancels Regulation Allowing Sea Sand Export

25 Juni 2025

Indonesia's Supreme Court Cancels Regulation Allowing Sea Sand Export

The judges stressed the importance of protecting and conserving the marine environment, including sea sand, to sustain the ecosystem's capacity.


Minister Hanif Stops Unauthorized Sea Sand Dredging on Pari Island

24 Januari 2025

Minister Hanif Stops Unauthorized Sea Sand Dredging on Pari Island

The sea sand dredging activity was allegedly carried out for the reclamation of a tourist resort on Pari Island.


Sea Sand Theft Costs Country Rp925.2 billion

2 November 2024

Sea Sand Theft Costs Country Rp925.2 billion

Celios presents the latest data on the losses suffered by the country due to the sea sand theft in the waters of Batam, Riau Islands.


Facts of Foreign Ships Caught Stealing Sea Sand in Batam

14 Oktober 2024

Facts of Foreign Ships Caught Stealing Sea Sand in Batam

The two ships held by the Indonesian Ministry in the case of stealing sea sand in Batam are Yang Cheng 6 Treetown Imo 83533245 and Zousun 9.


Indonesia Nabs Foreign Sand Dredgers in Batam; Sand Taken to Singapore

11 Oktober 2024

Indonesia Nabs Foreign Sand Dredgers in Batam; Sand Taken to Singapore

The Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries (KKP) arrested two sand dredging vessels in the waters of Batam Island, Riau Islands.


Indonesian Coastal Communities Stage Protest at Maritime Ministry to Reject Sea Sand Exports

10 Oktober 2024

Indonesian Coastal Communities Stage Protest at Maritime Ministry to Reject Sea Sand Exports

Indonesian coastal communities staged a protest in front of the Ministry of Marine Affairs building, reacting to the reopening of sea sand export.


Today's Top 3 News: 8 Best Places to Visit in Bali as a New Traveler

7 Oktober 2024

Today's Top 3 News: 8 Best Places to Visit in Bali as a New Traveler

Tempo English compiled the top 3 news on Monday, October 7, 2024.


Former Minister, Brother of President-Elect among Parties Vying for Sea Sand Permit in Indonesia

7 Oktober 2024

Former Minister, Brother of President-Elect among Parties Vying for Sea Sand Permit in Indonesia

An Indonesian Marine Ministry official said that 66 companies have applied for concession permits to manage sea sand.


Celios Warns of Blue Carbon Crisis Due to Sea Sand Export

3 Oktober 2024

Celios Warns of Blue Carbon Crisis Due to Sea Sand Export

Celios has released a comprehensive report analyzing the government's decision to reopen the sea sand export.