Lupa Kata Sandi? Klik di Sini

atau Masuk melalui

Belum Memiliki Akun Daftar di Sini


atau Daftar melalui

Sudah Memiliki Akun Masuk di Sini

Konfirmasi Email

Kami telah mengirimkan link aktivasi melalui email ke rudihamdani@gmail.com.

Klik link aktivasi dan dapatkan akses membaca 2 artikel gratis non Laput di koran dan Majalah Tempo

Jika Anda tidak menerima email,
Kirimkan Lagi Sekarang

General Gatot`s Controversy

Translator

Editor

3 April 2018 15:40 WIB

Former Indonesian National Armed Forces (TNI) chief Gatot Nurmantyo.

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The emergence of General Gatot Nurmantyo in the race for the presidency and vice-presidency is heating up the temperature of Indonesia's politics. He could well be an alternative to incumbent President Joko Widodo and his long-time challenger Prabowo Subianto. But Gatot's arrival will not be enough to resolve the democratic stagnation caused by a lack of ideas and leaders who can truly inspire.

General Gatot, who retired at the end of March, is being put forward by, among others, the Great Indonesia Movement (Gerindra) Party. The former commander of the Indonesian Military (TNI) is being considered as a possible running mate to Gerindra's chair Prabowo. Another name under consideration is Jakarta Governor Anies Baswedan. Deliberation amongst Jokowi's opponents is continuing, especially since it is not yet certain whether Prabowo is serious about running.

A recent proposal is to pair Gatot with Anies if Prabowo does not stand. That would certainly make the 2019 presidential election more interesting, although Gatot has so far been unable to offer any original ideas on how to improve matters of this nation.

On the contrary, Gatot is more known for his controversial views. When he was TNI commander, he spoke about "illegal" arms import rumors, which exacerbated tensions between TNI and the Indonesian National Police (Polri). Later it was found out that the weapons had been officially imported by Polri, but without a recommendation from TNI. 

He also proposed that TNI become involved in dealing with terrorism in a revised version of Law No. 15/2003. Moreover, he also ordered the Army to organize mass screenings of the classic movie The Eradication of the G30S/PKI Treachery-a film about the events surrounding the 1965 coup attempt based on the official State's version. Screening of this movie had been stopped after the reform movement in 1998 because it was considered too much part of the New Order regime's propaganda.

When Jakarta Governor Basuki Tjahaja Purnama, alias Ahok, was charged with blasphemy at the end of 2016, Gatot was believed to have made "maneuvers" for his own political gain. He was the only official who met with the 212 demonstrators wearing an Islamic white cap. Gatot claimed it was his way to win over the demonstrators, although others saw it as a sign that Gatot was, in fact, taking sides with them. Some made the accusation this was an effort on Gatot's part to accumulate political capital from Muslim voters. Surely it is not ethical for a TNI commander to play politics.

Therefore, questions need to be asked about Gatot's use of identity politics. This recipe proved effective in the Jakarta gubernatorial election. Ahok, who was initially very popular, not only lost, but was jailed. It would be very dangerous if Gatot were tempted to use a similar strategy. Identity politics will only cause further rifts among the people and has no relevance to the real problems this country is facing.

Gatot, who has said he is a close friend of businessman Tommy Winata, may well have no problems raising enough funds. But his participation in politics is not on a level with that of Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono in 2004. Long before challenging incumbent Megawati Sukarnoputri, Yudhoyono had set up the Democrat Party as his political vehicle. As a military figure, he was also able to offer a brisk leadership and better-planned management of the country- a weakness of the government at that time.

Prabowo, who was Jokowi's main rival in the 2014 election, followed the same path. Before contesting the 2009 election as Megawati's running mate, he established the Gerindra Party, despite the seriousness of the problems it faces. Gatot has none of this experience nor political capital.

Nevertheless, General Gatot has appeared at a time of democratic conservatism. The current political mechanism has failed to produce leaders of quality with new ideas to improve the nation. Issues that badly need new approaches include, among others: rampant corruption, social inequity and stagnant economic growth.

The nation's leaders should realize the causes of this tiresome political state of affairs. One of the culprits is the presidential threshold rule. The rule has a negative impact since it reduces the number of possible candidates for the presidency. Only parties or coalitions with 20 percent of seats in the House of Representatives or 25 percent of the national vote can put forward candidate pairings for the presidency and vice-presidency. This rule is hobbling democracy. At present, the only parties that can nominate a challenger to the incumbent are Gerindra and the Prosperous Justice Party, because the other parties have joined forces with Jokowi's allies. The number of possible challengers can be counted on the fingers of one hand. At this time of democratic fatigue, the name of Gatot has appeared – a controversial figure with untested leadership abilities. 

Read the full article in this week's edition of Tempo English Magazine



Indonesia`s Startup Investment at Rp39.8 tn  

14 Desember 2018

Indonesia`s Startup Investment at Rp39.8 tn  

A joint-research by Google and AT Kearney shows that investments in
Indonesia's startups have grown 68 times in the last five years


Jokowi Keeps Low Profile on Social Media  

14 Desember 2018

Jokowi Keeps Low Profile on Social Media  

President Joko Widodo or Jokowi once again mentioned the use of social
media during his speech at the Indonesia Business and Development Expo
2017


International Coffee Day: Solo to Give 5,000 Cups of Free Coffee  

14 Desember 2018

International Coffee Day: Solo to Give 5,000 Cups of Free Coffee  

Harjonagoro Traditional Market in Solo is preparing 5,000 cups
of coffee to be given out for free at the International Coffee
Day event, Oct. 1.


Ed Sheeran Cancels Jakarta Concert  

14 Desember 2018

Ed Sheeran Cancels Jakarta Concert  

Singer Ed Sheeran has canceled his concerts in Jakarta and
other Asian cities following a bike accident.


Halal Thai Restaurant in Bali  

14 Desember 2018

Halal Thai Restaurant in Bali  

Som Chai in Seminyak, Bali, can be considered to be one of
Bali`s Thai restaurants that serve several halal menus.


Top 5 Indonesian Athletes in 2018 Asian Para Games  

14 Desember 2018

Top 5 Indonesian Athletes in 2018 Asian Para Games  

Indonesia is targeting the top-seven rank in the Asian Para
Games 2018.


S. Sumatra Plans Restoration of Hundreds of Hectares of Peat Land

14 Desember 2018

S. Sumatra Plans Restoration of Hundreds of Hectares of Peat Land

Peat land restoration would cover around 594,231 hectares in
South Sumatra this year to preserve the environment, a
government official said.


Sperm Whale Ingested Plastic Waste; Serious Solution Required

14 Desember 2018

Sperm Whale Ingested Plastic Waste; Serious Solution Required

It is estimated 94 percent of plastic waste that enters the
ocean ends up on the seafloor, which threats the lives of
ocean`s creatures.


Roy Marten: Jokowi Leads Indonesia, Ahok Leads Jakarta

24 Oktober 2018

Roy Marten: Jokowi Leads Indonesia, Ahok Leads Jakarta

Actor Roy Marten relentlessly promotes Jokowi for President,
saying that the society had already shown enormous
supports.


Ousted Casillas Speaks of Triumph over Juventus

24 Oktober 2018

Ousted Casillas Speaks of Triumph over Juventus

The Blancos faces Champions League Top 16, needing only six
points to secure the round.