Lupa Kata Sandi? Klik di Sini

atau Masuk melalui

Belum Memiliki Akun Daftar di Sini


atau Daftar melalui

Sudah Memiliki Akun Masuk di Sini

Konfirmasi Email

Kami telah mengirimkan link aktivasi melalui email ke rudihamdani@gmail.com.

Klik link aktivasi dan dapatkan akses membaca 2 artikel gratis non Laput di koran dan Majalah Tempo

Jika Anda tidak menerima email,
Kirimkan Lagi Sekarang

The Ultimate Deal

Translator

Editor

5 September 2017 15:58 WIB

From left to right, Richard Adkerson, CEO of Arizona-based Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc.; Indonesian Finance Minister Sri Mulyani Indrawati; and Energy and Minerals Minister Ignasius Jonan speak prior to the start of a press conference in Jakarta, Aug. 29, 2017. AP

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The willingness of Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. to relinquish 51 percent of the shares in PT Freeport Indonesia to the Indonesian government should not fill us with unbounded joy.

There is still much work to do: from negotiating a price, finding the funds and deciding on the tax regulations to preventing rent-seekers from joining the divestment scheme. If it is not managed carefully, instead of bringing benefits to the people, the divestment could empty the government's coffers or just enrich a small number of people.

The ownership of the world's largest gold and copper mine in Papua has long been in dispute. The latest drama began in January when the government banned Freeport from exporting copper concentrate. In line with Government Regulation No. 1/2007 on the Mining of Minerals and Coal, the mining company is not allowed to export copper concentrate without building a smelter to refine it. This ban led to Freeport-McMoRan CEO Richard Adkerson threatening to take the government to arbitration for breaking the 1991 work contract.

While both sides exchanged threats, time was wasted, and 60 percent of Freeport's products were kept off the market. Even worse, the smelter at Gresik could not be built because of a strike by employees. All activities at the Grasberg mine stopped. This uncertainty also delayed payments of taxes, royalties, and dividends to the government. This state of affairs forced both sides, Richard Adkerson, Finance Minister Sri Mulyani and Energy Minister Ignasius Johan, to sit down together.

The agreement reached in August was very good and ambitious. Freeport accepted the change of status from work contract to special mining permit (IUPK) until 2041. This is a fundamental change, given that Freeport had viewed the work contract as a sacred document that could not be altered.

The work contract system gave Freeport complete freedom to act, while the IUPK sets certain limits. There are six components: restriction of the area, an increase of tax liability, increase in royalties, increase in the use of local components, divestment of a 51-percent shareholding to the government and downstream processing of mining products. On paper, Indonesia won the negotiations on points.

Reaching an agreement is one thing, but monitoring and realizing it is quite another. For example, the government will have to decide on the share price. As it has a 9.36-percent shareholding, the government needs to buy 41.64 percent to reach the 51 percent. The government has promised to pay the market price. But Freeport is bound to set a high price by considering the cost of its investment and the potential for profit. The setting of the share price is a shortcoming in Law No. 4/2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining, which does not specify the way the share price is calculated.

For example, last year Freeport offered a 10.64- percent shareholding for US$1.7 billion, or around Rp23.6 trillion. The Energy Ministry then established a valuation team, which came up with a figure of US$630 million, or 37 percent of the Freeport version. This difference was the result of the two sides using different starting points for the calculation. The government based its figure on repaying investment costs, while Freeport included the copper reserves until 2041.

The setting of the price cannot be separated from the overall calculations of profit and loss. For example, how will the taking over of a 51-percent shareholding in Freeport generate more than income to date from dividends, royalties, and taxes? It is estimated that the government would receive revenues totaling US$1.4 billion, or approximately Rp19.4 trillion until the year 2021. The government must be able to guarantee that it will receive more income from its majority shareholding.

The source of funds is also a complex issue. With a slowing economy, it is thought that the tax revenue target will not be met and that the government will have problems finding funds to buy the Freeport shares. The government is putting together a consortium including the Healthcare and Social Security Agency (BJPS), state-owned enterprises such as PT Inalum and PT Aneka Tambang and regional government-owned companies.

If the funding is insufficient, private companies could be involved. Maritime Affairs Coordinating Minister Luhut Binsar has indicated this might happen. But this calls for caution: the involvement of private companies might lead to a rerun of the games played by rent-seekers.

What happened with Kaltim Prima Coal (2003) and Newmont Nusa Tenggara (2010) must not be repeated. The government's plan to involve regional government-owned companies in the ownership of Newmont, for example, failed because the Bakrie business group was behind the regional government-owned company. The same business group was involved in Kaltim Prima Coal.

The Constitution states that the land, water, and natural resources in them shall be managed by the state and used for the greatest possible prosperity of the people. President Jokowi must ensure this noble aim is realized.

Read the full story in this week’s edition of Tempo English Magazine



Election Fraud in a Neighboring Country

17 jam lalu

Election Fraud in a Neighboring Country

Seven members of the Kuala Lumpur PPLN are proven to have inflated the number of voters for the 2024 elections.


Because the State Is Not an Entrepreneur

1 hari lalu

Because the State Is Not an Entrepreneur

The government plans to accelerate the privatization of state-owned enterprises. Stop paying out budget funds for state companies.


Ignoring the Rights of Indigenous People

2 hari lalu

Ignoring the Rights of Indigenous People

Indigenous people are taking legal action against the President and the DPR for delaying deliberations of a bill. It has taken second place to the int


BTN Syariah's Acquisition of Bank Muamalat

7 hari lalu

BTN Syariah's Acquisition of Bank Muamalat

The government is to combine BTN's Sharia business unit with Bank Muamalat. This could lead to problems.


Lackadaisical Disaster Mitigation

7 hari lalu

Lackadaisical Disaster Mitigation

Hydrometeorological disasters hit a number of areas in Indonesia. Ironically, mitigation efforts are not yet a priority.


Child Pornography Syndicate in Indonesia

8 hari lalu

Child Pornography Syndicate in Indonesia

The crime of child pornography is continuing to spread. Perpetrators can operate from inside the jail.


Jokowi's Hand in the Golkar Party

9 hari lalu

Jokowi's Hand in the Golkar Party

Jokowi has ambitions to take control of the Golkar Party. It is his new way to stay relevant to those in power.


The Backers of Illegal Tin Mining

12 hari lalu

The Backers of Illegal Tin Mining

The Attorney General's Office is investigating alleged corruption over tin mining permits in Bangka Belitung.


The Importance of the Right of Inquiry

13 hari lalu

The Importance of the Right of Inquiry

Jokowi is taking Indonesia right back to the start of the Reformasi era. The right of inquiry could be a way to save democracy.


Funding for the Hasty Free Lunch Program

14 hari lalu

Funding for the Hasty Free Lunch Program

Jokowi and his ministers begin tinkering with the budget for the free lunch program. It is not appropriate and highly risky.