The MK Verdict That Rejects Interfaith Marriage

2 February 2023 10:19 WIB

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The Constitutional Court (MK) panel of judges has rejected the lawsuit filed by E. Ramos Petege against Law No.1/1974 concerning Marriage. More specifically, the young man from Gabaikunu Village, Papua Province, aimed to help legalize interfaith marriage. 

MK chief justice Anwar Usman read the verdict in Jakarta, on January 31. The Constitutional Court in its legal considerations stated that there are interrelated interests and responsibilities of religion and the state in marriage.

“MK has provided a constitutional basis for the relationship between religion and the state in marriage law, that religion determines the validity of marriage, while the state determines the administrative validity of marriage within the legal framework," constitutional judge Enny Nurbaningsih state, the official MK website reported.

A Prerequisite, Not A Right

Enny explained, based on the formulation of Article 28B paragraph (1) of the 1945 Constitution, there are two rights that are explicitly guaranteed, namely the right to form a family and the right to maintain offspring. The next phrase shows that a valid marriage is a prerequisite in order to protect the two rights mentioned earlier.

That is, marriage is not placed as a right, but as a prerequisite for the exercise of the right to form a family and based on this description. There are fundamental differences between the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) and the 1945 Constitution in the context of protecting the right to marry.

The State Guarantees Legal Status of Citizens Through Legal Marriage

The Constitutional Court states that the country’s interference in the organization of marriages should not become a religious interpreter for the validity of marriages. In this case the state follows up on the results of the interpretation of religious institutions or organizations to ensure that marriages must be in accordance with their respective religions and beliefs.

According to the Constitutional Court, the provisions of Article 2 paragraph (1) of Law 1/1974 provide a corridor for the implementation of marriages that in order for a marriage to be valid, the marriage is carried out according to the laws of each religion and belief. The application of the provisions of Article 2 paragraph (1) does not impede anyone's freedom to choose their religion and belief.

NAUFAL RIDHWAN

Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News



Constitutional Court Judge Declared Guilty in Code of Ethics Violation

4 hari lalu

Constitutional Court Judge Declared Guilty in Code of Ethics Violation

Constitutional Court Honorary Council (MKMK) has officially handed a written warning to judge Guntur Hamzah.


Jokowi to See Brother-in-law Takes Oath as Constitutional Court Chief Justice

4 hari lalu

Jokowi to See Brother-in-law Takes Oath as Constitutional Court Chief Justice

President Jokowi will witness Anwar Usman take his oath as Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court (MK) today, March 20.


MK Chief Justice Anwar Usman Faces Questioning Over Verdict Fiasco

24 hari lalu

MK Chief Justice Anwar Usman Faces Questioning Over Verdict Fiasco

Constitutional Court (MK) chief justice Anwar Usman is reportedly set to be questioned by the court's honorary council.


Time for Indonesia Taking Action against Crimes in Myanmar

25 hari lalu

Time for Indonesia Taking Action against Crimes in Myanmar

Indonesia's Constitutional Court could make history and become a hero for the people of Myanmar and South East Asia.


Jokowi Claims Work Creation Regulation Develops Business, Create More Jobs

32 hari lalu

Jokowi Claims Work Creation Regulation Develops Business, Create More Jobs

Jokowi said that the most important thing in relation to the passing of the Work Creation Law is to build a good business ecosystem.


Garuda Indonesia Wins Lawsuit against 2 Lessors in Paris Court

35 hari lalu

Garuda Indonesia Wins Lawsuit against 2 Lessors in Paris Court

Flag carrier Garuda Indonesia, through its subsidiary Garuda Indonesia Holiday France (GIHF), won a judicial release lawsuit against two lessors.


Press Law Challenged Again at the Constitutional Court

38 hari lalu

Press Law Challenged Again at the Constitutional Court

The Press Law has once again been challenged for a constitutional review at the Constitutional Court (MK).


Why Constitutional Court Rejects Interfaith Marriage Judicial Review

45 hari lalu

Why Constitutional Court Rejects Interfaith Marriage Judicial Review

The Constitutional Court (MK) has rejected the judicial review application against the law on marriage.


Constitutional Court and the Alleged Minor Editorial Changes with Major Implications

54 hari lalu

Constitutional Court and the Alleged Minor Editorial Changes with Major Implications

A controversy arose which involves the Constitutional Court changing the substance of the dismissal verdict of a former supreme court judge.


Democratic Party Rejects MK Judicial Review on Closed-List Election

18 Januari 2023

Democratic Party Rejects MK Judicial Review on Closed-List Election

Democratic Party slams the MK review challenging the open-list ballots and requests a return to the closed-list electoral system.