Oligarchs Weaken Indonesia's Fight Against Corruption

Editor

Laila Afifa

3 December 2022 12:16 WIB

By: Charles Simabura and Haykal, researchers at the Center for Constitutional Studies (PUSaKO) and lecturers at the Faculty of Law, Universitas Andalas, Padang.

Indonesia’s efforts to fight government corruption are being corrupted from within parliament, backed by big business.

At the beginning of the 2000s, Indonesian voters said enough about corruption in politics. The Reform Order (1999) was designed to fight corruption. Then, in 2004, Indonesians elected President Yudhoyono largely on his promises to fight graft and corruption.

People demanded reform. Tools were put in place to attack the corruption endemic in public life that was holding back development.

But the system is failing. Indonesia’s own parliament, backed by big business interests, has succeeded in weakening the very system set up to fight corruption.

The tentacles of the oligarchs have wrapped themselves around the executive arm of government, where several cabinet members have considerable business interests. Indeed, 55 percent of Indonesia’s parliament members have significant business holdings.

The marriage between the ruler and business people is getting stronger in Indonesia's politics. 

The Reform Order resulted in the creation of institutions that were expected to be able to free Indonesia from corruption. The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) had the power to investigate corruption. The Constitutional Court acted as the guardian of the constitution. The Judicial Commission was intended to ensure proper behavior from judges. And the Ombudsman served as the ‘policeman’ of state officials. 

But these institutions have failed to meet expectations.  The fervor to fight graft that was there 20 years ago has faded. There has even been a revenge attack by corruptors backed by the oligarchs. A 2020 survey by Transparency International Indonesia showed the Indonesian Corruption Perception Index fell from 40 to 37. 

In addition, the People’s Representative body was considered the most corrupt institution in Indonesia. The numbers show why. Between 2004 and 2020, 274 members of local and national parliament were arrested.  Many MPs consider corruption eradication as a threat. 

The efforts to undo Indonesia’s anti-corruption framework began with efforts to review the Corruption Eradication Commission Law to the Constitutional Court, where, according to data, more than 20 requests for review have been submitted. At the end of President Joko Widodo’s first term, the parliament succeeded in pushing for a revision of the law. As a result, the Corruption Eradication Commission was weakened and was listed as an institution that the public no longer trusted.

It has since become a toothless tiger. The weakening of the anti-corruption body began with its leadership. There are also questions about the recruitment of commissioners whose commitment to eradicating corruption is problematic. Other commissioners have repeatedly violated the code of ethics, One chose to resign to avoid being fired. Legislation suspected of being corrupt was successfully passed because it did not receive supervision from the Corruption Eradication Commission.

There is a pattern of laws being drafted in secret and hastily passed which do not serve the interests of the public. The Anti-corruption body Law, the Mining Law, the Omnibus Law, and the Constitutional Court Law are all examples. The result is demonstrations. Any judicial review is usually rejected by the same people who passed the laws in the first place.

Parliament's efforts to gain control over anti-corruption institutions have become increasingly evident, especially in the process of recruiting the members of those institutions. MPs replaced one constitutional judge because he was seen to be in conflict with the parliament’s agenda after he helped cancel the promulgation of the Omnibus Law.

The way to stop the erosion of Indonesia's anti-corruption efforts must come from the top. But President Joko Widodo doesn’t seem to be taking any serious steps. People will remember his legacy as ignoring the Reform Order unless he takes radical moves before leaving office in 2024. 

Originally published under Creative Commons by 360info™.

*) DISCLAIMER

Articles published in the “Your Views & Stories” section of en.tempo.co website are personal opinions written by third parties, and cannot be related or attributed to en.tempo.co’s official stance.



Why We Need Healthy Forests for Healthy People

4 hari lalu

Why We Need Healthy Forests for Healthy People

People living in cities have begun to realize how vital access to forests, urban parks, and green spaces is for our mental health and well-being.


Leveraging Business in Ramadan through Content Creator Marketing

4 hari lalu

Leveraging Business in Ramadan through Content Creator Marketing

As the world's largest Muslim-populated nation, Indonesia sees an increase in economic activity during Ramadan.


Singapore to Tighten Shoe Recycling Controls following Investigation

4 hari lalu

Singapore to Tighten Shoe Recycling Controls following Investigation

The investigation found sneakers donated by Reuters in Singapore had instead been exported to Indonesia for resale.


Indonesia Not Interested in Having Diplomatic Ties with Israel; Here's Why

5 hari lalu

Indonesia Not Interested in Having Diplomatic Ties with Israel; Here's Why

Indonesia declared its independence in 1945 while Israel proclaimed its state establishment in 1948.


KPK Grills IPW Chair over Alleged Gratification Involving Deputy Minister

5 hari lalu

KPK Grills IPW Chair over Alleged Gratification Involving Deputy Minister

Indonesia Police Watch (IPW) chairman will be questioned by KPK today for his report regarding the alleged gratification of Deputy Minister of Law.


Norway, Indonesia Agree to Enhance Economic Cooperation

6 hari lalu

Norway, Indonesia Agree to Enhance Economic Cooperation

The Indonesian and Norwegian authorities have agreed to enhance cooperation in various aspects of the economic sector


Switzerland, Indonesia Sign Trade Promotion Cooperation Pact

6 hari lalu

Switzerland, Indonesia Sign Trade Promotion Cooperation Pact

Indonesian Trade Ministry has signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with the Swiss government for trade promotion cooperation.


Indonesia, Malaysia Discuss Steps to Improve Protection for Migrant Workers

6 hari lalu

Indonesia, Malaysia Discuss Steps to Improve Protection for Migrant Workers

Indonesia and Malaysia continue the discussion on optimizing the protection of Indonesian migrant workers.


Indonesia, U.S. Sign Deal to Develop Clean Energy

6 hari lalu

Indonesia, U.S. Sign Deal to Develop Clean Energy

The Indonesian Government and the United States signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) for the Clean Energy Working Group.


Lukas Enembe Corruption; KPK Confiscates Rp50.7bn, Freezes Bank Account of Rp81.8bn

8 hari lalu

Lukas Enembe Corruption; KPK Confiscates Rp50.7bn, Freezes Bank Account of Rp81.8bn

The Corruption Eradication Commission or KPK seizes Rp50.7 billion in the graft case of inactive Papua Governor Lukas Enembe.