Silencing Students Voice

Translator

TEMPO

Editor

Laila Afifa

9 July 2021 09:10 WIB

TEMPO.CO, JakartaNo matter how impolite it is, criticism of the government from students must not be muzzled. Allowing rectors to hold a position in state-owned companies weakens the independence of campuses.

When it comes to muzzling student criticism, the governments of Suharto and Joko Widodo seem just the same. The difference is in the method. During th Suharto era, repression was done by the implementation of the Normalization of Campus Life and the Student Coordination Board (NKK/BKK). Nowadays a different method is used: university rectors are controlled by giving them lucrative positions as commissioners of state-owned companies.

These rectors then become like bulls led by the nose: following the government's wishes. This makes universities easy to control. At the very least, rectors are reluctant to allow their students to criticize the government. This type of submission eventually gives rise to brownnosers.

When the University of Indonesia (UI) Student Executive Body (BEM) dubbed President Joko Widodo "the King of Lip Service" - because many of his statements were seen as differing from reality - rectorate was quick summon the students. The same repression was used last year when the UI BEM held a discussion titled #PapuanlivesMatter: Judicial Racism in Papua. The rector immediately claimed that this discussion was inappropriate and in breach of university regulations.

In response, students have to point out that campuses should always provide a space for academic freedom. University have a moral responsibility to criticize mistakes in governmnt policies. Campuses should not be bowing down to the authorities.

The phenomenon of rectors becoming governmnt hirelings has also occurred in other campuses. When students in large numbers opposd the revision to the Corruption Eradication Commission Law in 2019, for example, at least five rectors threatened their students with suspension if they joins the demmonstration. The rectors issued these reprimands after an appeal from the minister of research, technology, and higher education.

No less concerning is the fact that this subservience towards the authorities has now permeated adacemics' way of thinking. Some lecturers have, for example, stated that the responsibility of a campus is not to criticize the government, but to provide 'contructing inputs'.

Unfortunately, a growing number of lecturers adopt this wrong way of thinking. Their idea of a proper protest is in line with Jokowi's opinion about criticism. The president said that criticism must be conveyed in an orderly and polite way.

Read the Complete Story in Tempo English Magazine



Presidential Palace Denies Rumor of Jokowi Avoiding Mass Protest in Jakarta

1 hari lalu

Presidential Palace Denies Rumor of Jokowi Avoiding Mass Protest in Jakarta

President Jokowi worked at the Bogor Presidential Palace in West Java, on Friday, amid mass protests in front of the Jakarta presidential palace.


SETARA Doubts Jokowi's Human Rights Team

2 hari lalu

SETARA Doubts Jokowi's Human Rights Team

SETARA Institute strongly criticizes the formation of a team dedicated to the nonjudicial settlement of severe human rights violations.


Past Human Rights Violation Victims Compensated Under New Decree

3 hari lalu

Past Human Rights Violation Victims Compensated Under New Decree

A non-judicial settlement for severe past human rights violations team has been formed under the new Presidential Decree.


Jokowi Will Not Follow Joe Biden and Declare 'Pandemic is Over'

4 hari lalu

Jokowi Will Not Follow Joe Biden and Declare 'Pandemic is Over'

Jokowi prefers to wait for a decision from the World Health Organization (WHO).


Jokowi Inaugurates Cibitung-Cilincing Toll and Serpong-Balaraja Toll Section I

4 hari lalu

Jokowi Inaugurates Cibitung-Cilincing Toll and Serpong-Balaraja Toll Section I

President Joko "Jokowi" Widodo inaugurated two new toll roads that are expected to facilitate logistics distribution and reduce congestion.


Jokowi Responds to VP Candidacy Rumors, Jokowi: Says Who?

8 hari lalu

Jokowi Responds to VP Candidacy Rumors, Jokowi: Says Who?

President Jokowi questioned the source of the rumor suggesting that he could likely run for Vice Presidential candidacy.


Megawati: the Hike in Fuel Price Is Calculated Carefully

9 hari lalu

Megawati: the Hike in Fuel Price Is Calculated Carefully

Former president Megawati says the decision to reduce energy subsidies which is followed by the increase in fuel prices had been carefully calculated.


7 Students Injured in Protest against Fuel Price Hike

9 hari lalu

7 Students Injured in Protest against Fuel Price Hike

Seven students are injured allegedly due to excessive force and police brutality during today's protest against the increase in fuel prices.


Jokowi Issues Instruction to Use Electric Cars as Govt Officials' Vehicles

9 hari lalu

Jokowi Issues Instruction to Use Electric Cars as Govt Officials' Vehicles

The instruction is a manifestation of Jokowi's commitment to transition from fossil-based energy to green, renewable sources.


Students Clash with Police During Protest against Fuel Price Hike in Jakarta

9 hari lalu

Students Clash with Police During Protest against Fuel Price Hike in Jakarta

Today's demonstration against the hike in subsidized fuel prices in the Horse Statue area near Monas, Jakarta, turns into chaos.