The Rice Import Shambles

Translator

TEMPO

Editor

Laila Afifa

2 April 2021 09:25 WIB

Rice loading and unloading activities at the Cipinang Rice Main Market, Jakarta, Monday, March 8, 2021. The import allocation is divided into 500,000 tons for Government Rice Reserve (CBP) and 500,000 tons according to Bulog's needs. Tempo / Tony Hartawan

TEMPO.CO, JakartaThe twists and turns between Trade Minister Muhammad Lutfi and the Chief Executive Officer of the State Logistics Agency Budi Waseso over the plan to import rice is a result of the lack of clarity in food policy. We need a National Food Agency.

IN this country, rice is often seen as a political commodity. However, when ensuring supplies of this staple, politics should not come into play. Transparent and accountable technical considerations must be the ruling guide. Rice imports, if needed, must be seen as a government instrument to guarantee stocks of this staple.

Three indicators can be used to determine whether there is a need to import rice: falling domestic rice production, increasing market prices, and shortage of stocks at the State Logistics Agency (Bulog). Rice is usually imported if the three are met. They can also be used to evaluate the government's plan to import a million tons of rice this year.

Before getting embroiled in a long debate, it is important to realize the plan to import rice is still in the form of a memorandum of understanding between the governments of Indonesia and Thailand. According to Trade Minister Muhammad Lutfi, rice imports will not happen in the short term. President Joko Widodo has also guaranteed there will be no imports of rice before June. Still, politicians have taken advantage of rice import rumors to garner public sympathy. People have automatically loudly opposed the imports before they really understood the fundamentals of the issue.

Are rice imports needed right now? Looking at the first indicator, rice production is currently high because of a good harvest. The Central Statistics Agency (BPS) estimates that production from January to April was 14.5 million tons of rice, an increase of 27 percent over the same period last year.

With this abundant production, rice market prices are falling. According to the BPS, the price of medium quality rice at the beginning of March was lower than the month before, and also lower when compared with the same period last year. Imports are needed if the price exceeds one and a half times the normal value.

Turning to the third indicator, Bulog rice stocks at present are 923,000 tons. This is enough to meet its operational requirements for the next twelve months. However, stocks are relatively low compared to consumption of around 2.5 million tons of rice per month assuming annual per capita consumption of 111 kilograms.

Despite this, it needs stressing that according to Bulog Chief Executive Officer Budi Waseso, around 106,000 tons of rice stockpiles will soon be no longer fit for consumption. This rice is the remainder of 1.8 million tons imported in 2018. This means that Bulog stocks are actually only around 817,000 tons.

Unfortunately, poor public communication by the government resulted in rumors of out-of-control rice imports. Politicians have stoked these rumors for their own interests. The welfare of farmers, often used as an excuse, has actually suffered. The import rumors caused their crop prices to plunge.

Minister Lutfi should have explained the rice import plan in a transparent way from the outset. The public needs to know that as a result of the pandemic, rice stocks in international markets are unstable and there could be occasional shortages. This has the potential to trigger a food crisis. Therefore, the government needs to make preparations, including planning for rice import allocations.

If coordination in the cabinet was good, this fallout between officials would have been avoided. Budi Waseso's objections that Bulog will have problems accommodating the harvest or distributing rice stocks would never have arisen. Furthermore, those problems are not linked directly to rice imports. A number of Bulog's problems are caused by the organization's change of role. Bulog is no longer an organization tasked with holding buffer stocks of rice as it was during the New Order regime.

This polemic has revealed a more fundamental problem: the shambolic nature of our food politics. Ever since Bulog was turned into a public company, meaning it is now a business entity, it has been unable to properly implement its function to balance the interests of farmers and consumers. Bulog used to buy rice when prices fell because of abundant production, or flood the market when prices soared as a result of supply shortages.

Ironically, nothing has been heard of the National Food Agency, a body that should have been established within three years after Law No. 18/2012 on Foodstuffs was passed. This is the body that was supposed to have facilitated coordination on matters concerning food between the three relevant bodies, the ministry of trade, the ministry of agriculture, and the ministry of state-owned enterprises.

Without fundamental improvements to our food politics, the polemic over rice imports will continue being a political game for the elite. Meanwhile, farmer welfare will not improve, and consumer interests will remain unprotected.

Read the Complete Story in Tempo English Magazine



Jokowi Ratifies Largest Regional Trade Agreement

4 hari lalu

Jokowi Ratifies Largest Regional Trade Agreement

President Jokowi enacted a law that marks the ratification of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership


Indonesia, India Sign Rp15tn Trade Deal at TIIMM G20

10 hari lalu

Indonesia, India Sign Rp15tn Trade Deal at TIIMM G20

Indonesia and India sign a trade deal worth US$1 billion, or nearly Rp15 trillion, on the sidelines of the series of G20 events


Indonesia, Saudi Arabia Aim to Strengthen Trade Ties With CEPA

12 hari lalu

Indonesia, Saudi Arabia Aim to Strengthen Trade Ties With CEPA

Trade Minister Hasan predicts CEPA economic partnership between Indonesia and Saudi Arabia will soon commence.


Trade Minister on Instant Noodle Price: Wheat Prices to Drop in September

54 hari lalu

Trade Minister on Instant Noodle Price: Wheat Prices to Drop in September

Trade Minister Zulkifli Hasan is optimistic that the price of instant noodles will not increase three times as forecasted by Agriculture Minister.


JNE Pays Rp37mn to Compensate 3.4 Tons of Bansos Rice Damaged by Rain

5 Agustus 2022

JNE Pays Rp37mn to Compensate 3.4 Tons of Bansos Rice Damaged by Rain

The presidential aid rice (Banpres) is damaged due to rain during the delivery process by JNE from Bulog warehouse.


Prices of Basic Necessities in Surabaya Stable: Trade Minister

31 Juli 2022

Prices of Basic Necessities in Surabaya Stable: Trade Minister

Trade Minister Zulkifli Hasan has said prices of basic necessities in a number of traditional markets in Surabaya, East Java Province, are stable.


Trade Minister Outlines Government Supports for MSMEs

24 Juli 2022

Trade Minister Outlines Government Supports for MSMEs

Trade Minister Zulkifli Hasan has outlined the supports that the government is providing to micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) at AOE 2022


UK PM's Trade Envoy Meets Prabowo; Calls Indonesia 'Reliable' in Indo-Pacific

14 Juni 2022

UK PM's Trade Envoy Meets Prabowo; Calls Indonesia 'Reliable' in Indo-Pacific

Defense Minister Prabowo Subianto meets UK Prime Minister's Trade Envoy to Indonesia and ASEAN, Richard Graham MP on Monday.


Australian PM Talks on Revitalizing Trade Relationship in Indonesia Visit

8 Juni 2022

Australian PM Talks on Revitalizing Trade Relationship in Indonesia Visit

Australian PM Anthony Albanese visited Makassar on Tuesday which comes as part of his first official visit to Indonesia as Prime Minister.


Australia PM: Trade, Investment Relations with Indonesia a Priority

7 Juni 2022

Australia PM: Trade, Investment Relations with Indonesia a Priority

Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said Indonesia is on track to become the fifth largest economy in the world.