Political Power in Legislation

Translator

TEMPO

Editor

Laila Afifa

20 March 2021 13:08 WIB

TEMPO.CO, JakartaOur national legislative process is fraught with transactions to maintain various interests. The elimination of General Election Law and ITE Law discussions from the national legislative program is just a minor example.

As suspected, President Joko Widodo's speech regarding the need to revise Information and Electronic Transaction (ITE) Law has turned out to be just a lip service as the planned revision of the law that has sent many people to jail was dropped from the 2021 national legislative program or Prolegnas 2021. Jokowi said in his speech on February 15, that he would work with the House of Representatives (DPR) to revise the ITE Law "if it cannot provide a sense of justice." He should have followed up his statement by making sure that the revision is included in the Prolegnas. Obviously, the two articles in the law - on defamation and insult - have been very useful in muffling critical voices.

Prolegnas is a legislative normative mechanism stipulated in the legislation formulation law which describes it as a priority scale for formulating legislation to create the national legal system. But, in reality, the government and the DPR impelement this process in a pragmatic manner by cramming in all sorts of bills while discarding crucial ones such as the ITE Law revision.

The DPR and the government agreed on 33 bills to be included in the 2021 Prolegnas, among others, the bills on protection of religious leaders and symbols and on the capital city. The two topics seem to illustrate the current political character of the government, that is, accommodating unsubstantial religious aspirations to pave the way for legality of Jokowi's ambitious project.

They do not seem to care too much about fundamental rights of the people and democracy. In this digital era, the ITE Law has become an ultimate weapon for the law enforcement authorities to silence critcism against the government. The revision is needed to stop the criminalization of dissent. After all, the restorative justice regulation issued by National Police Chief Gen. Listyo Sigit Prabowo does not guarantee the end of the use of 'catchall' clauses of the ITE Law.

Their pragmatic approach is also visible in the decision to exclude the General Election Law revision from the Prolegnas. The revision was initially drafted, among others, to 'normalize' the regional head elections agreed to be held simultaneously in 2024, alongside the presidential and legislative elections.

After considering a myriad of problems in the 2019 elections - including the heavy burden on the poll officials - there was an aspiration to separate the three major political races. Almost all the factions at the DPR agreed. But President Jokowi then lobbied the chiefs of his supporting parties. Subsequently, all the parites changed course. It is impossible to rule out the notion that the decision was taken based on political calculations only.

The decision is also in stark contrast to the conspiracy to endorse the revision of the Anti-Corruption Law in 2019 and the Job Creation Law last year. The two bills were deliberated and passed without going through the Prolegnas. It is not surprising since the two regulations support the government's mmission to 'facilitate development.'

The government, with Senayan's support, uses the laws to reinforce its power. As a result, they often disregard democratic and human rights approaches in legislative processes. Trade, investment and capital interests have become primary objectives in formulating various laws.

Read the Complete Story in Tempo English Magazine



Poll: 83.5 Percent Jakartans Satisfied with Anies Baswedan's Performance

2 hari lalu

Poll: 83.5 Percent Jakartans Satisfied with Anies Baswedan's Performance

The latest PDB's telesurvey reveals that 83.8 percent of Jakartans are satisfied with Anies Baswedan and Riza's performance in leading Jakarta.


Personal Data Fabrication Faces Hefty Fine, Imprisonment in Latest Law

11 hari lalu

Personal Data Fabrication Faces Hefty Fine, Imprisonment in Latest Law

The House of Representatives (DPR) has ratified the Personal Data Protection Act on Wednesday.


Police Charge Madiun Man under ITE Law for Helping Bjorka

12 hari lalu

Police Charge Madiun Man under ITE Law for Helping Bjorka

A young man from Madiun, MAH, who was arrested previously for helping a hacker Bjorka is charged under a number of articles of ITE Law.


Jokowi Believed to Be Maintaining Political Influence Following Recent Events

32 hari lalu

Jokowi Believed to Be Maintaining Political Influence Following Recent Events

Indonesia Political Review executive believes President Jokowi is attempting to keep power close to his circle ahead of 2024 political year.


Politician Fadli Zon Deplores Police's 'Overreaction' Against Identity Politics

29 Juni 2022

Politician Fadli Zon Deplores Police's 'Overreaction' Against Identity Politics

Fadli Zon criticized Police's plan on establishing a task force dedicated to preventing a rise in identity politics ahead of the election.


Labor Party Files Judicial Review of Legislation Formation Law

27 Juni 2022

Labor Party Files Judicial Review of Legislation Formation Law

The Labor Party is set to file a judicial review of the Law on the legislation formation (UU PPP) on Monday, June 27, 2022, at 14:00 Jakarta time.


Biden Signs Gun Safety Bill into Law

25 Juni 2022

Biden Signs Gun Safety Bill into Law

U.S. President Joe Biden on Saturday signs into law the first major federal gun reform in three decades.


Jokowi Passes Law Overseeing the Omnibus Method

20 Juni 2022

Jokowi Passes Law Overseeing the Omnibus Method

The President has officially ratified Law No.13/2022 on legislation formation (UU PPP), which regulates the omnibus law legislation method.


Labor Party to Stage Simultaneous Rally Today Rejecting Job Creation Law

15 Juni 2022

Labor Party to Stage Simultaneous Rally Today Rejecting Job Creation Law

Labor Party President Said Iqbal confirmed that they will hold simultaneous demonstrations across regions of Indonesia today, June 15, 2022.


Setara Institute Deems DPR Justifying Any Means for Job Creation Law

25 Mei 2022

Setara Institute Deems DPR Justifying Any Means for Job Creation Law

Setara Institute criticizes the DPR for ratifying the Revised Law No. 12 of 2011 concerning the drafting of laws and regulations for Job Creation Law.