After the Passing of Omnibus Law

Translator

Non Koresponden

Editor

Laila Afifa

22 October 2020 22:28 WIB

By: Julio Achmadi | Member of the Partnership for Governance Reform

The Draft of Job Creation Bill (RUU Cipta Kerja) has been passed in the plenary meeting of the House of Representatives (DPR) on October 5. Despite reaping a lot of criticism and rejection from various groups, DPR and the government insisted on completing the discussion of the law which is hoped to attract foreign investors. Now, the Constitutional Court (MK) is expected to uphold justice for the people, especially those who are affected by the enforcement of this law.

The law which was created using the omnibus method can be challenged in MK through judicial review in the form of formal and material review. A formal review is conducted to make sure whether there is a legal flaw in the legalization process. MK has issued a decision giving a time limit of 45 days from the date a law is passed and published in the State Gazette as a deadline for conducting a formal review.

The contents of the formal review can be very diverse. It could be about the incompatibility of the form and format of the Job Creation Law, the absence of a legal basis for the omnibus law method, the non-involvement of the community in the deliberation process, hasty ratification in a health emergency situation, and non-conformity with DPR regulations.

A material review is carried out to further investigate articles that are suspected of being unconstitutional, such as the opinion that the law does not have human rights, an anti-environmental perspective, and deprives people's living space. Unlike the formal review, the material review has no deadline. The judicial review applicants can muster a lot of support from the affected groups, academics, and experts in various fields to present substantive arguments in the material review process. The material review process of the Job Creation Law would be very draining and time-consuming. Thus, the applicant should start preparing ammunition as soon as possible by consolidating with all elements of civil society that are potentially affected.

However, Jorawati Simarmata (2017) found the fact that, during 2003-2015, MK had conducted a judicial review of 400 laws with a total of 212 granted decisions. But MK did not grant any formal review. He concluded that formal review was difficult to grant because MK prioritized material review and the principle of benefit. Previous experiences become the best lessons for the future. Therefore, this should be the applicant's note in submitting a judicial review of the Job Creation Law to MK.

I believe the option to conduct a judicial review on the Job Creation Law will be tinged with conflicts of interest and allegations of the non-independence of MK after the revision of the Constitutional Court Law last September. However, there are not many other remedies that are currently provided in the Indonesian legal system.

Apart from legal efforts, people who reject the Job Creation Law can take political resistance, for example by not electing those who sit in the DPR at this time in the next general election. Demonstrations become a rather tough choice in a pandemic situation, but people are still doing it to show their genuine concern about this law. They are willing to fight with Covid-19 to voice their opinions which were not heard by the DPR and government. The impact of the passing of the Job Creation Law could also spread to local elections this year, especially with the option not to vote (golput).

The government has justified every means to expedite the process of passing the draft Job Creation Law. The DPR and the government played cat and mouse and took advantage of the minimum amount of direct pressure during the pandemic. The use of repressive and intimidating methods was also enforced to suppress resistance. The security approach taken by the police previous week before the passing of this law has undermined democracy and violated people's rights to express opinions and voice their aspirations.

The public anger and disappointment of the passing of the Job Creation Law have now rolled to MK as people's last bastion of resistance. MK is expected to enforce justice over the government and people's representatives who have done wrong.

*)

DISCLAIMER

Articles published in the “Your Views & Stories” section of en.tempo.co website are personal opinions written by third parties, and cannot be related or attributed to en.tempo.co’s official stance.



House Approves Capital Injections for Garuda Indonesia

5 hari lalu

House Approves Capital Injections for Garuda Indonesia

DPR Commission XI has approved the government's plan to disburse Rp7.5 trillion in state capital injections (PMN) to Garuda Indonesia.


Thousands of Farmers to Stage Protest Demanding Agrarian Reform

9 hari lalu

Thousands of Farmers to Stage Protest Demanding Agrarian Reform

The Labor Party president Said Iqbal announces that thousands of farmers and laborers are set to stage a protest at the State Palace on Saturday.


Personal Data Protection Bill Ratification Opens a 'New Era of Data Management'

12 hari lalu

Personal Data Protection Bill Ratification Opens a 'New Era of Data Management'

DPR officially ratifies the Personal Data Protection Bill (RUU) in the fifth plenary held on Tuesday, September 20.


DPR Passes Personal Data Protection Bill into Law

12 hari lalu

DPR Passes Personal Data Protection Bill into Law

The House of Representatives (DPR) has officially passed the personal data protection bill in today's plenary meeting, September 20, 2022.


1,000 Online Taxi Drivers to Stage Yet Another Protest in DPR

12 hari lalu

1,000 Online Taxi Drivers to Stage Yet Another Protest in DPR

Online taxi drivers planned to hold a demonstration on Wednesday, September 21, 2022, in front of the House of Representatives (DPR) Building.


DPR to Pass Personal Data Protection Bill Today

12 hari lalu

DPR to Pass Personal Data Protection Bill Today

The House of Representatives (DPR) is set to pass the personal data protection bill today, September 20, 2022.


House Legislator Laments 'Offensive' TNI Remark a Repercussion

16 hari lalu

House Legislator Laments 'Offensive' TNI Remark a Repercussion

Efendi Simbolon laments the intimidation he received after his remark against the National Armed Forces (TNI) went viral.


DPR Legislator Who Likened TNI to a Mob Publicly Apologizes

18 hari lalu

DPR Legislator Who Likened TNI to a Mob Publicly Apologizes

Legislator Effendi Simbolon issued a public apology after he likened TNI personnel to a mob in a House Hearing on Monday.


MKD: Puan Maharani Birthday Celebration Does Not Violate Ethics Code

18 hari lalu

MKD: Puan Maharani Birthday Celebration Does Not Violate Ethics Code

MKD states that the celebration of Puan Maharani's birthday during the DPR plenary session was not a violation of code of ethics.


Global Oil Prices Drop; Govt Urged to Cancel Fuel Price Hike

24 hari lalu

Global Oil Prices Drop; Govt Urged to Cancel Fuel Price Hike

DPR member from the PKS faction, Mulyanto, urged the government to revoke the policy on the hike in fuel prices as the global oil prices dropped.