Lupa Kata Sandi? Klik di Sini

atau Masuk melalui

Belum Memiliki Akun Daftar di Sini


atau Daftar melalui

Sudah Memiliki Akun Masuk di Sini

Konfirmasi Email

Kami telah mengirimkan link aktivasi melalui email ke rudihamdani@gmail.com.

Klik link aktivasi dan dapatkan akses membaca 2 artikel gratis non Laput di koran dan Majalah Tempo

Jika Anda tidak menerima email,
Kirimkan Lagi Sekarang

Not a Grandstand Project

Translator

Editor

9 February 2016 09:26 WIB

President Joko Widodo sign an inscription stone marking the ground breaking the Jakarta-Bandung high speed train project. TEMPO/Aditya Herlambang Putra

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - President Jokowi may have taken a wrong and dangerous path when he signed, in quick succession, two contradictory regulations that will impact the Jakarta-Bandung rapid rail project.

The first, Presidential Regulation No. 107/2015 on the acceleration of infrastructure and facilities, stipulates that the Rp74 trillion project will be entirely funded by the private sector, in other words by the Indonesia-China Fast Railway Consortium. The government will not provide any guarantees, the clause that assured the Chinese consortium's victory over its rival Japanese bidder. 

Three months later, in January, Jokowi signed Presidential Regulation No. 3/2016 on the acceleration of strategic national projects, which raised the possibility of a guarantee for the Jakarta-Bandung venture. The appendix stated that it could be characterized as strategic and as such could qualify for a government guarantee.

Next came the inconsistent statements from the president's own ministers. According to Finance Minister Bambang Brodjonegoro, the government would not be providing any financial guarantees. State-Owned Enterprises Minister Rini Soemarno then weighed in, saying the government would have to give a 'political guarantee' an expression that is difficult to separate from a financial guarantee if the project runs into money problems. 

The contradiction between the two regulations could have serious implications for the future of the project. What is more, the experience of other nations teaches us that rapid rail projects lose money, or at least have problems turning a profit. For example, Japan's Tkaid Shinkansen broke even only after eight years of operation. Of five fast rail projects in China, only one has recovered its costs, while the rest are still in the red. And a rapid-rail consortium in Taiwan is on the verge of bankruptcy.

The Taiwan example is relevant to the Jakarta-Bandung rapid railway because the Taiwan High Speed Rail Consortium initially promised to provide all the funds needed a total of US$18 billion, or Rp243 trillion. The involvement of the Taiwanese government was limited to a feasibility study. The Taiwanese-Japanese consortium obtained a 35-year concession under a build-own-transfer arrangement.

The 339-kilometer line linking Taipei in the north with Kaohsiung in the south was completed in 2007, 20 years after the feasibility study. Money trickled in and in the fourth year the consortium booked a 'profit', but this was apparently the result of accounting tricks.

After 20 years of operation, the government was forced to inject capital into the operation to keep it running. But this did not solve the problem. Now the consortium is pondering a restructuring, which would include extending the concession period from 35 to 75 years. With a mountain of debt and a long concession period, rapid rail in this case is just not turning out to be a profitable business.

Given the experiences of Japan, Taiwan and even China itself, there is a huge risk of losses or outright failure. The project might grind to a halt at the financing stage, but this could also happen after the railway starts operating. For example, the Taiwan consortium was laid low by its inability to bear the financial burden of depreciation and interest rates. It is highly likely Indonesia will face similar problems.

The four state-owned companies that are part of the Indonesia-China consortium are now in a state of confusion as they try to raise Rp750 billion of initial capital, or 60 percent of the partnership's shares. This burden will only grow when the loan is added on. With such a large ownership share, Indonesia also has more to lose in the event of failure than the Chinese.

To ensure there are no unwelcome surprises, Jokowi should revise Presidential Regulation No. 3/2016. And the government should reevaluate the capacity of the consortium to raise the necessary funds and the ability of our state enterprises to bear the expected operational losses. If the project does not make business sense, the government should not hesitate to delay or cancel it.

The provision of mass rapid transport links to reduce congestion and improve the welfare of the people is a noble goal. But this ideal should not be reduced to mere grandstanding because of a prestige project. The government should assure its people that this project is viable as a business. We do not want the experience of Taiwan to be repeated here. (*)

Read the full story in this week's editio of Tempo English Magazine



Jokowi's Hand in the Golkar Party

3 jam lalu

Jokowi's Hand in the Golkar Party

Jokowi has ambitions to take control of the Golkar Party. It is his new way to stay relevant to those in power.


The Backers of Illegal Tin Mining

3 hari lalu

The Backers of Illegal Tin Mining

The Attorney General's Office is investigating alleged corruption over tin mining permits in Bangka Belitung.


The Importance of the Right of Inquiry

4 hari lalu

The Importance of the Right of Inquiry

Jokowi is taking Indonesia right back to the start of the Reformasi era. The right of inquiry could be a way to save democracy.


Funding for the Hasty Free Lunch Program

4 hari lalu

Funding for the Hasty Free Lunch Program

Jokowi and his ministers begin tinkering with the budget for the free lunch program. It is not appropriate and highly risky.


Empty Words about Nusantara Forest City

6 hari lalu

Empty Words about Nusantara Forest City

The claim that the Nusantara Capital City will be a sustainable forest city is just empty words from officials.


Minister Bahlil's Grease Money

11 hari lalu

Minister Bahlil's Grease Money

Investment Minister Bahlil Lahadalia has revoked mining permits and then reissued them. There are indications of illegal buying and selling of permits


The Grip of Corruption on Our Courts

11 hari lalu

The Grip of Corruption on Our Courts

Corruption is spreading through the Indonesian legal system. This is illustrated by the case involving the Supreme Court secretary.


Pretending to Reduce Emissions

13 hari lalu

Pretending to Reduce Emissions

The REDD+ program brought in money but failed to protect forests. Millions of hectares of forests become concession areas for mining corporations.


The Spread of Illegal Rice Levies

14 hari lalu

The Spread of Illegal Rice Levies

Illegal levies are worsening the shortages of subsidized rice. Price rises are caused by, among other things, corruption.


The Return of Meat Import Quotas

18 hari lalu

The Return of Meat Import Quotas

The government, once again, is applying a policy of import quotas. This will lead to collusion and bribery.